Tuesday, September 13, 2016

Oil Zombies, living on a prayer (and a little hope)...

Interesting piece on Bloomberg.com today about "zombie oil companies," which are oil producers that have pursued various restructuring strategies with their creditors in hopes they can survive long enough for prices to turnaround.  The companies have engaged in "distressed exchanges":
Such exchanges — defined by Moody's Investors Service as when a troubled company offers its lenders new or restructured debt, securities, cash, or other assets, that amount to a smaller commitment than the original IOU — could have big implications for debt markets as they stretch out the current credit cycle and result in even greater losses for investors.
As noted in the article, in the current down cycle, investors have recovered on average a paltry 21% of the value of assets from bankrupt energy companies (versus an historical average of 59%).

Unfortunately, as the International Energy Agency stated today, they now believe it will take another year before markets balance out.  The future is not bright for these zombies. As I've noted previously, investors and firms are simply cutting off their nose to spite their face."  Extending the life of energy firms through these distressed exchanges means they will continue to pump oil to generate revenues, but this will also extend the low price environment.

Investors should've cut their losses when those assets were more valuable. The (market) force is not with them.  By allowing the zombies to survive a little longer, the supply shakeout is pushed further out; and speculators trying to time the bottom prevents prices from reaching a kill point. Instead, what we have is a bunch of slowly dying zombies living on a prayer for higher prices.  Whenever there is a bit of positive news (a decline in inventories for example), speculators push prices up too fast which gives everyone a little hope, but hope does not a trend make...

Wednesday, September 7, 2016

Steady Price of Crude

As I mentioned in my last post, I don't see oil prices moving to either extreme price predicted by two forecasters a couple months ago.  An article in Bloomberg here provides some support for my view. From the article:
All but one of 15 senior oil traders and executives interviewed this week at the annual Asia-Pacific Petroleum Conference in Singapore expect crude to remain between $40 and $60 a barrel over the next 12 months. Brent crude has traded in that range for the past five months.
The issue, as I've stated, is that commodity markets dominated by investors do not allow prices to fall low enough to generate the shake out needed to balance the market. Prices also tend to rise quickly enticing new production. So-called "savvy" investors are looking to time the bottom and ride the price rise up.  As one trader stated, the issue is that prices go up too fast, and this happens because of the herd mentality of Wall Street.

The current commodity deflation is a consequence of the bubble Wall Street promoted from 2002 to 2012, and most prices will be depressed for a long time because of the over-investment that occurred as a reaction to that bubble.  We consumers are getting some needed relief...

Thursday, July 28, 2016

Is it $80 or $10?

I've been meaning to write this particular post for awhile, but other priorities have taken up much of my time--finishing up some formal articles--publish or perish!

About a month ago two very different oil price forecasts came out within days of each other.  First, a report by Raymond James financial advisers forecast oil at $80 in 2017, and shortly after that publication Gary Shilling came out with a forecast of $10-$20.  The RJ forecast is based on projections of a "tightening in supply and demand dynamics" over the next year, though more so on supply issues, and you can read a bit more about their forecast in this Bloomberg article.

Shilling's projection is based on a combination of factors: high inventories; producers pumping oil to generate cash flow in order to survive the shakeout, and the Saudis pumping oil to drive them out; a slowing global economy; and the impact from a rise in the value of the dollar as a safe haven in uncertain times.  Shilling's views can be found in his Bloomberg piece here.

It's quite possible that both forecasts are right!  Shilling does not provide a time frame, though it appears he is describing a near term crash in prices, whereas Raymond James' forecast is for sometime in 2017.  Futures prices suggest some movement higher over the next year, as the price of a July 2017 contract is currently $47.07.  However, while the current futures oil price curve is in contango, it is not steep enough to support the oil storage trade.  In his piece, Shilling provides some estimates of storage costs: floating storage is about $1.13/month, rail storage 40 cents, and Cushing oil tanks cost 25 cents/month.  Given the current contango structure, alternative storage facilities (rail and sea) are no longer profitable, so, as contracts mature from trades that were previously profitable, those traders will have to dump oil into the market, putting downward pressure on prices in the short term.

Therefore, my view is somewhere in the middle.  The current market has too much excess crude AND too much excess refined products, as recent reports indicate.  While the fundamentals dictate near term crude weakness, it's difficult to see oil falling to $20 or less because investor/speculators (and they dominate trading in futures markets) will be looking for the bottom and an opportunity to start buying again.   This is what also puts a lid on future prices of crude: since investors dominate price discovery in futures markets, prices will continue to seesaw and make it impossible for producers to adjust to real forces; that is, prices most likely will not reach a low enough price to create the shake out necessary for stronger future prices.

My best guess is prices will not fall below $30 in the short term, and they will not exceed $70 in 2017, assuming no major supply shock event.  Then again, in this topsy turvy world, who would've predicted a guy like Donald Trump would have a shot at becoming president of the United States....

Tuesday, June 28, 2016

Brexit and Oil Prices

I was going to write a piece to update recent issues with oil prices, and came across this article which essentially includes the point I wanted to make: despite no change in the global physical markets for oil, prices are declining, which is the result of the strengthening US dollar caused by Brexit.  The relevant parts:
Moreover, price movements are also largely dictated by the interaction between global currencies. Since oil is priced in U.S. dollars, any strengthening of the dollar relative to other currencies makes crude more expensive, cutting into demand and pushing prices down. The crash of the British pound over the past two trading days is having this effect. The pound is now down 10 percent from the pre-Bexit vote last week; the euro is down 3 percent. The U.S. dollar index, which measures the currency’s strength against a basket of six major currencies, is up. The dollar jumped by another 1 percent on Monday, to a three-month high.It is no coincidence that oil prices plunged at the same time as the dollar surged. “We all got it wrong,” Michael Lynch, president of Strategic Energy & Economic Research, said in an interview with Bloomberg. “This is strengthening the dollar, which is bad for commodities."
 As I've argued in several pieces, I believe the reasoning that explains the decline is hogwash! A change in the dollar does not cause a rapid change in oil demand; the explanation is that the dollar-oil trade is a favorite of hedge funds and other global investors.

Thursday, June 23, 2016

21P

It's a been awhile....

I've been taking a breather after the end of our semester.  I've been planning on an oil market update, and will do so in the next week.  This post is about something a bit on the lighter side, a concert review.  I took my stepson to see 21 Pilots down at Canal Side in Buffalo on Tuesday June 21.   My stepson got me interested in them, and he really wanted to see them.  I've got to say they are very entertaining!

Only two guys in the band, a drummer and the lead singer who plays mainly piano, with a little guitar and ukulele sprinkled in here and there.  They have a hardcore fan base, and it's easy to see why.  They literally interact with the audience, setting up an additional drum set and key board in the middle of us.  The lead singer also climbed into a giant hamster ball and rolled over the top of the audience at one point.  Despite the theatrics, their music is engaging, and the lyrics are thoughtful and philosophical.  They even do a couple of covers for us old folk--Twist and Shout and Can't Help Falling in Love.

I've been to a lot of concerts, and I would give this one a 10 out of 10--my stepson gave it a 20!

If you haven't heard of them, check out my current favorite: Tear in My Heart.


Sunday, May 1, 2016

Another one bites the dust...And the Saudis keep on pumpin'

Ultra petroleum, a small Houston-based energy firm:
"The oil market is suffering its worst slump in decades, brought on by a glut of production. Crude inventories are at their highest levels since 1930 in the U.S., according to data from the Energy Information Administration.
Much of the problem can be traced to a record-breaking surge in U.S. oil production that wouldn’t have been possible without a tremendous amount of debt. Many independent drillers, the small producers that drove the shale boom, outspent cash flow even when oil was $100 a barrel, and made up the difference with bank loans and high-yield bonds."

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-05-01/ultra-petroleum-files-for-bankruptcy-citing-3-9-billion-debt

The other interesting piece of news, though it's not been a secret, the Saudis vow to keep pumping and keep market share. My favorite part:

"Saudi Arabia's determination to keep pumping more oil into global markets brings to mind its former oil minister Sheikh Yamani, who said back in 2000 that the Stone Age did not end for a lack of stones, and the oil age will not end for a lack of oil.
Those working for him at the time (including me), interpreted this as a warning to OPEC about the pursuit of high oil prices: namely, that it would just speed up the development of alternative technologies and drive away customers, leaving oil sitting beneath the ground without buyers."

http://www.bloomberg.com/gadfly/articles/2016-05-01/saudi-arabia-heeds-sheikh-yamani-oil-warning

Saturday, April 30, 2016

Dallas Fed warns on oil prices

I wonder if a Fed warning will cause some profit taking next week?  The article basically states the arguments made here: inventories are still rising, and:
"Speculative long positions on crude oil have risen to all-time highs on the futures markets, a sign that the rebound may have lost touch with fundamentals."
Read the article here: Dallas Fed warns..